E
Elle
May 23, 2026
Five stars aren’t enough.
I have owed this book a review for over a month, because apparently the better the book is, the less capable I am of forming useful sentences. But this is the best book I have read in a long time. Certainly this year. Honestly, probably since the last Pam Godwin book.
Only Pam Godwin could write a 740 page book and have me read it twice in less than two months. Twice. In five weeks. I read a ridiculous amount of books and her writing still stands in a league of its own. She is gifted. The prose, the tension, the way she builds damaged people, it is just different.
I struggle so much with reviews for my god tier books because when a book hits this hard, simple tropes and the usual romance words feel inadequate.
Rise of Ink and Smoke is not just “dark romance” with messy trauma bonding, or something as basic as found family but kinky. It is beautiful. Complicated, brutal, emotional, intimate beautiful. I could go on, you get the drift.
Wolf absolutely wrecked me. He has always felt like the smartest one in the Frozen trilogy to me, the one who sees everything, understands more than people give him credit for, and this book cements that. He is deeply damaged but he knows it. He owns who he is, even when he is still trying to survive what was done to him. Watching him try to adapt to a world that is not actively trying to kill him, while still carrying the PTSD from his childhood and captivity, was heartbreaking AND fascinating.
And when he spirals, thinking his sexuality…