Home / Gay / Girl Next Door: A Hilarious Sapphic Rom-Com Brimming with Secrets, Yearning, and Heart
Gay

Girl Next Door: A Hilarious Sapphic Rom-Com Brimming with Secrets, Yearning, and Heart

Rachel Meredith
4.3 / 5.0
Published: 2025

Description

Returning to your hometown is supposed to be a fresh start, but for Maya, it feels more like walking into a minefield of unfinished business. At twenty-four, she is desperate to reinvent herself, yet the past has a funny way of resurfacing when you least expect it. When she moves back into the house next door to her childhood best friend—and secret first crush—the fragile walls she built around her heart begin to crumble. This story captures that messy, exhilarating period of your twenties where every decision feels monumental and every heartbeat carries the weight of a decade of longing. As Maya navigates complicated family dynamics and the sharp sting of old wounds, she finds herself drawn back to the one person who truly knows her. What begins as a series of awkward encounters and hilarious missteps quickly spirals into a second-chance romance that is as tender as it is transformative. Perfect for readers who crave a story that balances wit with raw emotional honesty, this novel explores the courage it takes to be vulnerable. It is a warm, engrossing look at home, identity, and the beautiful, terrifying possibility of falling for the person who has been there all along.

Customer Reviews

Top 3 from Amazon
J
Jason
September 18, 2025
Verified Purchase

Funny, sexy and deeply sweet

The fastest I’ve read a book in a long time @rachelmeredithwrites A perfect window into that time in your 20s when you’re trying to figure out who you are and who you love. Sweet, charming, sexy and funny. Where you want to skip ahead to find out what happens, but then have to go back so as not to miss something. READ IT.
L
Lauren
October 12, 2025

Messy romance

Thank you to Harper Perennial for the ARC. These opinions are my own. This is such a fascinating premise. There's a hot new sapphic romance titled Girl Next Door (yes, the same title as this book). It's written under a pseudonym, but Joe tells his best friend MC that it's clearly written by their high school friend, Nora. And Nora wrote it about her relationship with MC, even though they never were together. So MC returns home to find out more. This is a very messy version of a romance. There are so many secrets and lies. In addition to MC, Nora, and Joe, we have many other key players, including MC's family. And every single one is complex and flawed. My favorite parts were the scenes with the high school literary club. And I also enjoyed all the library scenes. I'm such a sucker for book content in books. But some of the main plots weren't as good a fit for me. I recommend this for people who enjoy morally grey main characters. CW: cheating 3.5 stars rounded up
R
Rhonda
April 3, 2026

Cute story

This was a nice , easy read with an engrossing story line and relatable characters. I really enjoyed it. Read this book!